A fun, family-friendly mince pie taste-test competition is a brilliant way to settle the debate. It’s inexpensive, great entertainment, and a lovely way to bring everyone together on a winter evening.
Here’s how to organise one that’s as delicious as it is memorable.
Step 1: Gather a Wide Selection of Mince Pies
The joy of the competition lies in variety, so aim to collect pies from a good mix of places:
Supermarkets: Pick up own-brand, premium, gluten-free and “luxury” ranges.
Local bakeries: Many independents bake their own pastry and mincemeat, offering something unique.
Farm shops: Ideal for finding buttery, crumbly pies made with regional ingredients.
Artisan producers or Christmas markets: Great if you want to add a few wild cards.
Aim for at least six different boxes, but more is always merrier.
Step 2: Keep It Blind for Fair Judging
Blind tasting avoids bias and keeps the competition fun.
Remove the pies from packaging.
Place each variety on a numbered plate or board.
Keep the packaging hidden until the end.
Give everyone a tasting sheet (simple is best!).
This adds a game-show element that children especially enjoy.
Step 3: Decide on the Scoring Categories
To keep judging consistent, set clear categories such as:
Appearance: Golden colour? Attractive shape?
Pastry: Flaky, buttery, crumbly, too dry or too soft?
Filling: Sweetness level, spice blend, texture, richness.
Overall flavour: Does everything work together?
Value for money: Reveal prices after tasting and let everyone score.
A 1–5 or 1–10 scale works well.
Step 4: Create a Festive Tasting Atmosphere
Turn the taste test into a mini-party. Try:
Christmas jumpers
Warm drinks (mulled wine, hot chocolate or spiced apple juice)
A Christmas playlist
Twinkly lights or a small table display
It transforms an ordinary evening into a fun Christmas tradition.
Step 5: Reveal the Winners
Once the scoring sheets are complete:
Collect and tally the numbers.
Reveal each mince pie’s brand or bakery one by one.
Crown your winners, overall champion, best pastry, best value, most unusual, etc.
You may find surprising results. Sometimes a budget supermarket box beats artisan producers, or a tiny local bakery wins big.
Step 6: Turn It Into an Annual Tradition
Many families choose to make the competition part of their yearly countdown to Christmas. Keep a record of the winners, take photos for your scrapbook or social media, and look forward to seeing which bakery or supermarket triumphs next year.
You’ll also be supporting local makers and discovering new festive favourites along the way.
A mince pie taste-test competition is a delightful way to share festive fun without needing to spend a fortune. It encourages family bonding, supports local businesses, and—most importantly—lets everyone indulge in one of Christmas’s greatest treats.
Will a luxury supermarket pie win your heart? Or will the humble local bakery take the crown? There’s only one way to find out…
Also, why not put the results up on your social media accounts?