Since its release in 1988, this action-packed thriller has become a cultural touchstone, and every festive season, the argument resurfaces.
Let’s look into the pros and cons of this contentious issue to determine whether John McClane’s explosive escapades deserve a place in the Christmas film canon.
The Case for Die Hard as a Christmas Movie
Set During Christmas
The film takes place on Christmas Eve, at a Christmas party in Nakatomi Plaza. The festive backdrop is integral to the plot, as McClane’s reason for being there is to reconcile with his estranged wife during the Christmas period.
Christmas Themes
At its core, Die Hard touches on themes of family, redemption, and togetherness — hallmarks of the Christmas season. McClane’s determination to save his wife and the hostages can be interpreted as an ultimate act of Christmas spirit.
Christmas Aesthetics and Music
The film is peppered with Christmas imagery, from decorations to Santa hats (including one with the darkly humorous “Now I have a machine gun. Ho-ho-ho”). Additionally, the soundtrack includes festive tunes like "Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow!" and "Christmas in Hollis" by Run-D.M.C.
Cult Status Among Fans
Many fans have adopted Die Hard as a Christmas tradition, watching it annually during December. For them, it embodies the unconventional yet festive spirit of the season.
The Case Against Die Hard as a Christmas Movie
Not About Christmas
While the film is set during Christmas, Christmas itself is not central to the story. The plot revolves around McClane’s battle against terrorists, with the festive setting serving as little more than a backdrop.
Genre Mismatch
Traditional Christmas movies typically fall into the categories of family-friendly, heartwarming, or comedic. As a high-octane action thriller with intense violence, Die Hard doesn’t fit this mould.
Absence of Christmas Spirit
Critics argue that the film lacks the sentimental or moral lessons typically associated with Christmas movies. McClane’s journey is more about survival and heroism than spreading goodwill or Christmas cheer.
Creator’s Intent
Some point to comments by the film’s creators, who have offered mixed opinions. Screenwriter Steven E. de Souza has leaned into the Christmas movie label, but director John McTiernan has been less definitive, describing it more as a “movie about redemption.”
Why the Debate Persists
The debate over Die Hard taps into broader questions about what defines a Christmas movie. Is it simply the presence of Christmas elements, or must the story revolve around the Christmas spirit and traditions? As audiences continue to redefine holiday norms and embrace unconventional favourites, the line between “Christmas movie” and “movie set at Christmas” has blurred.
Final Thoughts
Whether or not you consider Die Hard a Christmas movie ultimately comes down to personal interpretation. For some, it’s a Christmas staple that injects a bit of adrenaline into the season.
For others, it’s a thrilling action film that happens to occur during Christmas. Either way, the debate ensures that Die Hard remains a beloved and enduring part of pop culture.
So, where do you stand? Is Die Hard a Christmas movie, or is it just a great action flick with a festive backdrop? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!