Discovering Genuine Artisan Cheeses for Your Christmas Cheeseboard

As Christmas draws near, many of us begin to prepare for festive gatherings and indulgent feasts. 

Amidst the mince pies, mulled wine, and roasted delights, one star of the holiday table often gets overlooked: the cheeseboard.

For those who appreciate the finer things, seeking out genuine artisan cheeses can elevate your festive spread and impress even the most discerning guests.

Why Artisan Cheeses?

In a world of mass-produced dairy, artisan cheeses stand out for their unique flavours, rich textures, and heritage. Unlike their factory-made counterparts, artisan cheeses are crafted in small batches by skilled cheesemakers who respect time-honoured techniques and use high-quality, often locally sourced ingredients. Each cheese tells a story of its region, the animals that provide the milk, and the hands that shape it.

The effort and care invested into creating these cheeses mean that you won’t find two batches exactly the same. This diversity makes artisan cheeses a delightful adventure for your Christmas cheeseboard, offering something unique for every palate.

What Makes a Perfect Christmas Cheeseboard?

A well-balanced cheeseboard is key to impressing your guests. You’ll want to curate a selection that offers a range of textures and flavours, from soft and creamy to firm and sharp. Here's a guide to building a cheeseboard that celebrates the best of artisan cheese-making:

1. Soft and Creamy

For the creamy category, a luscious brie or camembert is a festive favourite. Look for an artisan producer who uses unpasteurised milk for a richer, more complex flavour. English options like Tunworth or a locally made Somerset brie are fantastic choices. These cheeses are indulgent and best served with a crusty baguette or artisan crackers.

2. Blue Cheeses

No Christmas cheeseboard is complete without a blue cheese. Stilton, the ‘king of cheeses,’ is a British classic, but there are other exceptional blues to explore. A wedge of artisan Shropshire Blue adds a striking colour and deep, nutty flavour to your board. Or, for something truly special, seek out a smaller, lesser-known producer who crafts blue cheeses by hand.

3. Hard Cheeses

Cheddar is a staple for most cheeseboards, but if you want to impress, skip the supermarket versions and find a handmade, cloth-bound cheddar. West Country Farmhouse Cheddar, for example, is made using traditional methods and matured for at least a year, developing an earthy, nutty complexity. A crumbly Lancashire or an artisan Caerphilly also make excellent additions, adding a robust, savoury element to your selection.

4. Goat’s Cheese

For a fresh and tangy contrast, include a goat’s cheese. Artisan varieties often come with a natural rind and a more pronounced flavour than their mass-produced counterparts. Ticklemore or Ragstone are both British-made options, offering a beautifully creamy texture and a delicate citrus tang that pairs well with fruit or honey.

5. Washed-Rind Cheeses

For the adventurous, a washed-rind cheese can be a bold choice. These cheeses, often matured by repeatedly washing the rind in brine or alcohol, develop strong aromas and deep, complex flavours. Stinking Bishop, a British favourite, is famously pungent but delightfully creamy on the palate. It’s a real showstopper for those who enjoy more robust cheeses.

Where to Find Genuine Artisan Cheeses

Now that you’ve got a better idea of what to include, the next step is sourcing your cheeses. While supermarkets may stock some artisan varieties, for a truly authentic experience, consider visiting a local cheesemonger or a farmer’s market. Many artisan cheesemakers sell directly to consumers at Christmas markets or through specialist online retailers, offering a much wider selection than you’ll find on the high street.

If you're in the UK, look for cheeses with Protected Designation of Origin (PDO) status, which guarantees the product is made in a specific region using traditional methods. British classics like Stilton, West Country Cheddar, and Single Gloucester all boast this mark of quality.

You might also consider putting together a cheeseboard with international artisan cheeses. French Comté, Italian Gorgonzola, and Spanish Manchego can all add an extra layer of sophistication to your festive spread, and many specialist retailers import these delicacies.

Pairing Your Cheeses

Once you've curated your cheeseboard, consider the accompaniments. Serve your cheeses with a selection of artisan crackers, fresh fruit like grapes or figs, and a drizzle of honey or chutney. A crisp white wine or a rich, full-bodied red often pairs well with most cheeses, though for a truly festive touch, a glass of port with your blue cheese is a time-honoured combination.

This Christmas, treat your guests—and yourself—to the indulgence of genuine artisan cheeses. By selecting varieties that showcase craftsmanship, heritage, and unique flavours, your cheeseboard will be the highlight of the holiday feast. 

Whether you stick to British favourites or add some international flair, the art of cheese selection will ensure your festive celebrations are as delicious as they are memorable.